Tommy Breuer was a scumbag. He was a total prick, the type of alpha male bully who teenage girls lost their tongues over. Years ago he was the captain of the football team, the star wide receiver who caught a sixty-two yard pass in the end zone to lead the Macarthur High Wildcats to its first state final’s victory. Yes, the crowd went wild and yes, he went on to be crowned prom king, homecoming king and about a million other bullshit titles.
Tommy Breuer was such a douche it was sickening. While most of the seniors were driving mom’s minivan to school, he’d skid into the teacher’s parking lot in a freshly-waxed Mercedes. He rocked a fresh tan year-round and not one hair on his head was ever out of place. He wore clothes emblazoned with logos from designers that rappers rhymed about. .Locust Hills was a blue-collar town, and the Breuers were in a class by themselves; a family that everyone wished they were born into.
There wasn’t a person alive who could’ve gotten away with as much bullshit as Tommy. He was untouchable and everyone knew it. Even the principal of the school would stop mid conversation to praise him in the hallway about some spectacular play he made on the field.
Now Natalia DeMarko was no outcast, believe me. Yes, she struggled to keep up with the kids in her honors’ classes, but she was still sharper than most. She was a trendsetter, and could turn thrift store rags into dresses you’d see in high-end storefronts. She wasn’t a cheerleader (in MacArthur High the cheerleaders were all anorexics with bad skin), but she was the only natural blonde in Locust Hills whose rep wasn’t damaged by rumors of stoned one nighters under the bleachers.
Regardless, Tommy Breuer was still out of her league. Every girl in her junior class was floored the first day they sat together at lunch. When she started climbing out of his Benz before homeroom every day it made headlines. Yes, Natalia was incredibly beautiful and was offered several modeling jobs for popular teen magazines, but she was Natalia DeMarko and he was Tommy Breuer. To the gossip-hungry teens at Macarthur High, those two together just didn’t make sense.
Now, it had been four years since Tommy caught that game-winning pass, but he still wouldn’t shut up about it. It’d been four years since he last flipped over a freshman’s lunch tray, but he was still cracking up over the memory of some loser he covered in chocolate milk and strawberry Jell-O. It’d also been four years since he and two of his boys sodomized Giovanni Sorenzito in the equipment room, but he still jerked off thinking about it.
Graduation was a lifetime ago, but it was still common to catch him parked a block past MacArthur High, tossing PBR cans out of the window, waiting for some sophomore with a low-rider jeans and zero self esteem to pass by. He was a vulture. No, a vulture is a scavenger. Tommy Breuer was something much worse.
Natalia knew this all going in. It was no secret. Every one of his sins was public knowledge. She knew that he yelled the “N” word whenever Torii Webster, the only black girl in school, passed him in the hall. She knew that he bragged about deflowering more than two dozen freshmen. She even knew that he spread lies about the few girls who actually had the guts to turn him down.
Natalia knew it all, but when Tommy Breuer told her she had the perfect ass, she melted the way any other girl would’ve. She blushed and thanked him. If she could travel back in time she would’ve slapped him, or tossed her iced chai in his face. But she didn’t. He was Tommy Breuer and she felt lucky to be noticed by him.
Tommy could’ve had any girl he wanted, and he’d chosen her. Yes, he cheated on her with the girl who sat in front of her in History. Yes, she caught him with his hand buried underneath Susie Gatz’s skirt at her birthday party. But none of those infractions were enough to make her leave him. No matter how abusive he treated her, Natalia wasn’t going to be the first girl ever to dump Tommy Breuer.
Natalia could’ve filled a spiral with reasons to break up. But in the end it was Tommy who pulled the plug. One week after graduation, Natalia was two months late and had seen the dreaded pink plus sign.
She had planned to go off to college that September, but she was blinded by naïve excitement over starting her new family. She circled baby outfits and cribs in catalogs. She never imagined herself as the motherly type, but in her eyes, getting knocked up was a sign from above. It meant that her and Tommy were destined to be.
Tommy of course, disagreed.
“Take care of it,” he warned. He squeezed her shoulders, crushing her frail bones with his meaty hands. Whenever he was angry, he’d spit when he shouted. His pupils would shrink to little pin-heads and his breath would stink of spoiled Chinese food. “I’m not going to be a fucking dad. Get that shit taken care of or I’ll shove you down the fucking stairs again.”
Natalia convinced herself that he was right; that they weren’t ready to have a baby yet. There’d be plenty of time for that anyway. They had a whole lifetime together and when the time was right, then they’d be able to start their family.
She pawned some of her mother’s jewelry to cover the abortion. She begged Tommy to take her to the clinic, but he was busy, and she had to take the bus. She sat by herself for the entire fifty-five minute ride pretending to read the latest issue of Cosmo.
After it was over, she’d never felt so alone. But deep down, she knew wasn’t alone. She had Tommy. She couldn’t wait to be back in his arms; to lay naked on his back porch underneath the stars. Walking home from the bus stop, she could already taste his sweat on her lips.
That night Tommy dumped her.
“Why would I want to stay with a whore like you?” he spit. “You’re damaged goods. You just had an abortion for fucks sake.”
Tommy Breuer was a scumbag. In a perfect world, bad things happen to bad people and all good dogs go to heaven. But this was reality. There was no such thing as miracles, divine intervention, karma, or any of that other bullshit. Evil people got away with evil on a daily basis. Tommy Breuer was no exception.
He was blessed with a perpetual “Get out of jail free” card and had everything including a full scholarship to any school he wanted. Not that he needed a handout or anything. His father had died when he was in diapers and left him a bottomless bank account to waste. His mother was the patron saint of the single parent. You’d be amazed how someone filled with misogyny could’ve had such a loving relationship with his mother.
Mrs. Breuer of course despised Natalia and wasn’t shy about showing her true feelings. She couldn’t bear the thought of Tommy dating someone from Natalia’s side of town. As pretty as she was, Natalia couldn’t hide the fact that she’d always be trash from the docks.
When Mrs. Breuer died choking on a chunk of filet mignon, Tommy was devastated. After a lifetime of causing harm and distress to everyone around him, finally something bad had happened. Natalia was overjoyed.
She reread the obituary over and over. She even highlighted the line, “Marissa Breuer is survived by her son Tommy, a MacArthur high school graduate and former Hillman trophy winner.
Natalia pictured Tommy sitting in the front row at the wake, trying to act hard. His eyes would tear and his voice would crack, but he’d never let anyone see him cry. But when he was alone in his empty house, the waterworks would start. He’d down a fifth of scotch and turn into a blubbering mess. That’s how close they were. Natalia would’ve done anything to witness that.
“You’re sick,” Giovanni told her. Natalia was normally the quiet one who sat in the back of the classroom, staring blankly out the window. But now, she was pacing circles in Barry Goldstein’s basement, chain-smoking and ashing into the empty beer bottles lined up on the washing machine. For the first time in her life, she was on fire.
“Maybe,” Natalie agreed. “But that fuck deserves it.”
“He’s an asshole, but what you’re suggesting is illegal,” Giovanni said.
“Not to mention immoral, obscene, and downright disgusting,” Torii added.
Torii looked like a dwarf lounging in an over-sized leather chair. Her hair was puffed out in a Foxy Brown style afro. She wasn’t overweight, but often wore clothes two sizes too small, making her look thicker than she was. She reapplied a layer of lip-gloss and smacked her lips together.
“Yeah Natalia,” Barry said. “Tommy was a dildo, but you have to let it go. Even if we wanted to do what you’re suggesting, there’s no way we’d be able to pull it off.”
“Why not? I have the whole thing planned out.”
“Walk us through it then. How the hell are we going to get her out of there?”
“I’m not breaking into a funeral home and jacking a dead body,” Torii said. “No fucking way.”
“You don’t have to,” Natalia said. She pulled out a fresh stick and lit it off of Barry’s. He blushed. Girls that looked like Natalia never gave him the time of day. “You’re the driver,” she continued. “All I need you to do is keep the car running while we take care of business.”
“You are not putting some dead bitch in my mom’s Pathfinder. I can’t have that. My mom catches one whiff of corpse and I’m a dead mother fucker.”
“First off, it won’t smell. They already embalmed her and filled her with all kinds of flowery shit. And second, we need you. I don’t have a car, Barry’s is in the shop, and Giovanni drives a rice-box.”
“Count me out,” Torii said. “I don’t care if that bitch stinks like roses. Not gonna happen.”
“Even if we had the transportation, it’s not like we can walk in to Johnson’s Funeral Home and carry her out,” Giovanni said, fidgeting in her chair. Her hands were tiny and covered in cigarette burns. She tugged on her white stockings and wiped her hands on her plaid miniskirt. If she were alone she would’ve tore off her clothes and curled up into a tiny ball. She was completely on edge being in a room with more than two people.
“I’ve already scoped the place out,” Natalia said. “Around back, there’s a window in the director’s office. All we need to do is give it a little tap with a hammer, crawl in, find the room she’s in and we’re gold. There’s no alarm, so we can totally take our time.”
“Why would there be?” Barry laughed. “It’s not like Maywood Heights has a corpse-theft problem.”
“Alarm or no alarm,” Giovanni scowled, scratching at the back of her neck. Her chalk-white skin was covered in red tracks from her fingernails. Out of the three girls in the basement, Giovanni would’ve been the prettiest if only she would stop picking at her skin. Her face was potholed with pock marks and acne scars. “I say we get in and out. I don’t want to spend any more time than I have to in there.”
“I don’t know why you’re all still discussing this. You’re going to have a long ass walk from the funeral home to Oak Street.”
“Tommy lives on Pine,” Natalia corrected.
“Pine, Oak, who gives a fuck?” Torii sprung from her chair and waved her finger in Natalia’s face. Her nails were obnoxiously long and painted antacid pink. “We’re not putting any dead bitches in my mom’s ride.”
Barry opened another beer. He swallowed and the first gulp got stuck in his throat. Foam spilled from his lips onto the floor. His eyes darted around the room, hoping that no one noticed.
“It would be a messed up thing to do,” Barry slurred. “And Tommy really does deserve to be fucked with.”
“I want to hurt Tommy as badly as you. But stealing his mother’s corpse and propping her up on his front lawn, that’s stepping way the fuck over the line.”
“With Tommy Breuer there is no line,” Natalia said, not even considering backing down.
“Natalia, you two broke up years ago. I think it’s time you got over it.”
“Get over it,” she charged. “Get over it. The cocksucker ruined my life. He ruined all of our lives.”
“High school was forever ago. I don’t even think about any of that anymore,” Barry said, a layer of foam mustached across his upper lip.
“He called you a dirty, kike, Jew cocksucker every day for seven years,” Natalia charged. “And you,” she pointed at Torii, “What was it Tommy called you? Please don’t make me remind you?”
Torii sat back down and draped her legs over the side of the leather chair. She steamed on the inside, but couldn’t find the right words to scream. Besides, she knew Natalia was right. Tommy Breuer deserved to be crippled. If they couldn’t do it physically, emotionally was the next best thing.
“What if we wrap her up in a drop-cloth?” Giovanni asked, inching closer to the circle. She had dreamed about revenge for years. Natalia’s plan wasn’t what she fantasized but it was way more plausible then stapling his scrotum to an oak tree. “We could wrap her up air tight and then she wouldn’t smell at all.”
“That would work,” Barry added. He’d also imagined countless ways to hurt Tommy, but never had the guts to do anything. Even after Tommy held him down and spray-painted a swastika on his chest all he was able to do is run home crying. It took him forty minutes of scrubbing to remove it. Forty minutes of cursing under his breath. Forty minutes of standing in the cold shower, piss dripping down the inside of his leg. He rubbed the imaginary spot on his chest and shivered.
“I don’t know,” Torii said, coming around. Tommy’s degrading nick-name for her was just the tip of the iceberg. Nobody but her, Tommy and David Collette knew about the time she’d stayed after school to work on a photography project and the two groped her in the dark room. When she resisted they held her face in a tray full of developer until she let them do whatever they wanted. “Say you’re able to break in and jack the body. And just say we shove the bitch in the back of the car. We bring her to Tommy’s house and then what? We hold her up in front of his bedroom window and make her dance?”
“Something like that,” Natalia said.
“Picture the look on that smug bastard’s face,” Barry added. “He’s home, all safe in bed. All of a sudden there’s a tap at the window. He thinks it’s one of his boys. He gets up to check it out and BOOM! He’s face to face with his dead mother. He’ll wet himself. Hell he might even have a heart attack. That would be so perfect.”
“And we wouldn’t be murderers or anything,” Giovanni said, trying to convince herself. “It wouldn’t be our fault if he dropped dead of fright.”
“Because Tommy’s going to drop dead at the sight of a corpse,” Torii hissed.
“A girl can dream can’t she,” Giovanni mumbled.
“So it’s settled,” Natalia said, taking charge. “Everyone change into something tight and black. We’ll meet in front of the Packshaw Diner at midnight.”
—–
Giovanni and Barry were beyond nervous. Their fingernails littered the backseat of Torii’s mother’s SUV. If Torii glanced in her rear view she would’ve had a meltdown. Lucky for them she was lost in a tunnel; her eyes pinned and focused on the road before her. The others were in the dream with her, staring blankly out their windows. The four of them didn’t even have a chance to buckle their seatbelts before Barry pulled out a bag. While they had often blacked out together, this time Natalia felt strange indulging. She wanted to keep her senses sharp in case anything went sideways. But she could tell her group was on edge and in order to comfort them, she huffed a dime-size bump on her wrist.
Torii killed the headlights and lowered the stereo. Barry’s stomach gurgled loudly. Natalia bounced in her seat. While everyone in the car was trying to find a way to back out, she was surgeon-ready. When they pulled in front of the funeral home, she opened her door before the car came to a complete stop.
“So what’s the plan?”
“Wait by the door. I’ll go around back and let you in. Torii, keep this thing running. If you see any law, give us three quick honks.”
“If I see any law, I’m ghost.”
“Whatever. Come on guys. Time to party.”
The three barreled out of the car. Torii counted to thirty and then piled another bump on her dashboard. The only reason she even hung out with Natalia was that her and her friends were a never-ending source of free drugs. Now here she was, an accessory. With a possession charge already on the books, a B&E would’ve meant jail time.
“Screw it,” she said as a fresh bump disappeared up her nose. She closed her eyes and fell into the backseat.
——-
“Torii, let’s go.”
Natalia’s face was inches from Torii’s, her menthol breath burning her sensitive nostrils. She waved her away weakly. Natalia grabbed her shoulders and shook her.
“Drive, damn it.”
Torii shook her head and turned the key in the ignition. The car was still running and buzzed loudly. Confused, she shrugged and threw the car in gear.
“That was intense,” Barry stuttered.
“Make a left at the light.”
“I can’t believe we did that. Damn, that was so intense.”
“No, a left. A fucking left.”
“We were so cool. So god damn cool.”
“Torii, open your eyes. Pull over. I’m driving.”
“I got this. Damn Natalia, who flipped your bitch switch.”
“Just pay attention. Crash us into a telephone pole and it’s going to be difficult explaining the body in the trunk to five-o.”
“I’m not gonna crash. Besides this ride’s a tank. I’ll plow through any telephone pole.”
“I wish we had that on video. I’ve never been so on edge before. So intense.”
“Make a right here. Then a left on 3rd.”
“Can you believe we didn’t get caught? That was so easy. I can’t believe how easy that was.”
“Pull in here,” Natalia directed. Tommy’s house was the second from a dead end which made it perfect for a covert assault. The Pathfinder stopped abruptly, bumping the metal frame of the dead end sign and bending it back.
“I didn’t think I had it in me. I thought I’d skirt out for sure.”
“Barry, will you shut up for a second,” Natalia barked. In the backseat, Giovanni was catatonic, but Barry was much worse. He hadn’t stopped shaking since he climbed back in the car. If Natalia had better options, she never would’ve chosen such amateurs. But she didn’t. More importantly she needed bodies, people who’d bow to her will. Giovanni and Barry might’ve been rejects, but they were rejects she could control.
Torii on the other hand, was a different story. She tapped out another bump on the dash and hovered over it.
“Good idea,” Barry said. “Pass that bag back here.”
“Are you mad? Do any of you have any idea about the severity of the situation we’re involved in? We broke into a funeral home and stole a corpse. We’re about to drag a five-foot mass of rotting flesh over to Tommy Breuer’s house, where we’re going to use it to inflict serious mental damage. Torii can’t keep her eyes open she’s so garbaged and you want to join her?”
“I just thought-”
“After. We disappear after.”
“Fine.” Barry crossed his arms in front of his chest. He was enraged and Natalia knew it. But she couldn’t worry about that now. Experience dictated that he would keep his mouth shut. “So what’s the plan?” he whimpered into his sweat-shirt.
“Tommy’s window is around back. It’s the first one you’ll come to. You and Giovanni are going to carry Mrs. Breuer back there.”
“Wait, why are we the ones doing all the work?”
“Shut up and let me finish.” Natalia’s patience was running thin. She made a mental note to dull her tone before she continued. She could tell the line between her and the group was a stressed wire that could snap at any moment. “You two are going to bring her around back. While you’re setting up, I’m going to sneak in through the front door and make sure he’s in his room. No sense going through all this if he’s not even home.”
“Why can’t I be the one to sneak in while you’re setting up?”
“Because I know the layout of the house. I also know where they hide the spare key.”
Giovanni dug her fingernails into her cheek. She scratched at a row of fresh scabs. They fell to the floor, leaving tiny white moons on her face. Natalia worried that she wasn’t going to be able to get her out of the car, let alone to go through with the plan. She continued anyway, speaking in slow forceful syllables.
“When I see that everything’s straight, I’ll text you. Once I do, Giovanni, tap on his window and wake the son of a bitch up. Then Barry you get the old bitch on her feet. Make sure he can get a good look at her face. And I don’t need to tell the two of you to stay invisible. It’s dark back there, so he shouldn’t see you, but if he does-”
“Trust me, we got this.”
“Perfect. Ok. Game time..”
Barry and Giovanni stayed frozen until Natalia was halfway up the walkway. She turned and shot them an icy stare. In tandem, the two opened the trunk and robotically carried the body into the backyard. The yard was dark like Natalia said and Barry stumbled over the garden hose. Mrs. Breuer fell from his grip and hit the grass with a soft thud.
Giovanni held back tears as they picked her back up. The back of her eyeballs burned, but she’d have to wait till later to cry. When she was safe under her blankets she’d sniff another bump and all the fear would go away. Giovanni swallowed and tasted sulfur.
Natalia removed a loose brick from the walkway and found the key exactly where it’d been hidden since the Breuer’s moved in. She was so petrified her team would abandon the plan and leave her behind she dry heaved onto the front step. She wiped the bile from her lips and turned the key in the door.
Tommy’s house was decorated in the same New Mexican style she remembered. The bright orange and yellow walls mocked her. She remembered standing in the very same living room and being ripped apart by Mrs. Breuer years ago. Mrs. Breuer’s words replayed in her mind. “Trash like you doesn’t belong with my son. Get out of my house before you stain my carpets.” Even more blows struck her when she remembered Tommy cowering timidly behind her, not coming to her defense.
Natalia sat on the oak-colored couch and sank into the leather cushions. The first time she made out with Tommy was on that couch. Natalia remembered his mouth tasting like steak sauce and even though she was three days into shark week, his right hand forcefully pushed into her jeans, snapping open her button-fly. In the background David Letterman read a monologue off of a teleprompter as Tommy dry-humped her to climax.
Natalia exhaled and hugged a throw pillow to her chest. She smiled and felt Tommy’s hands roughly squeezing her breasts. She slid her hand up the front of her shirt and felt her heart thumping against her ribcage.
When the night started, Natalia was a soldier, a hundred-pound chunk of solid steel, but being back in Tommy’s living room, with memories swarming around her, she was as helpless as when he used to pin her down. She needed something to carry her through the next few steps. She emptied a capsule on the pillow and shaped it into a tiny hill. She leaned forward, smelling fresh rain scented fabric cleaner as she inhaled.
The couch vibrated underneath her. For a second Natalia thought she was still in the passenger seat of the Pathfinder, swerving down a bumpy road. Outside, headlights darted in front of the bay window, filling the room with yellow and slapping her back into reality. Natalia gained her bearings and reached for her cell. The display flashed that she had two new text messages, both from Barry; both wondering where she was.
Natalia was dizzy, but she pulled enough composure to creep down the hallway to Tommy’s room. Careful to stay stealth, she opened the door and saw him sleeping soundly. The air conditioner filled the quiet with a soft hum. Years ago, Tommy would order her to keep her mouth shut when they were screwing. Mrs. Breuer slept two doors down and even though the whole block could hear him throwing her around the room, Natalia wasn’t allowed to so much as whisper, for fear of waking her.
Natalia’s phone vibrated again. She wanted to treasure her memories a little longer, and floated in the past for a few moments before checking it. The newest message was from Barry, saying they were bailing.
Natalia bit her lip and raced outside to catch them but she was too late. She cursed under her breath as the Pathfinder’s taillights sped away.
Natalia found Mrs. Breuer’s body sprawled out on the back deck, her arms draped over the metal legs of a barbecue grill. Natalia struggled to lift her, but the dead weight was too much. She huffed and accidentally knocked over a flowerpot, the ceramic smashing into four pieces.
Emptiness smothered her insides. Yes, Tommy would be shattered tomorrow when the gardener told him in Spanglish that there was a dead woman on the patio. But that wasn’t enough. A) She wouldn’t be there to see the horror on his face and B) He needed to be the one to find the body.
Blood simmered beneath her flesh. The rage building in her chest combined with the painkillers in her bloodstream made her lose control.
“Fuck it,” she muttered.
Acting on impulse, Natalia summoned enough adrenaline to carry the body into the house all the way to Tommy’s bedroom door. She pushed it open and pulled the body into the room. She inhaled and filled her lungs with as much oxygen as they’d allow.
“Tommy,” she screamed, “Wake up you son of a bitch.”
His body lay perfectly still. Most nights, Tommy collapsed into an alcohol-induced coma, a state of dreamless sleep that took more than a buzzing alarm clock to arouse him. The empty bottles stacked on his dresser confirmed tonight was no different.
“Tommy, wake up.”
Natalia lifted her leg as high as she could and kicked at his shoulder. Standing on one tired leg, she lost her balance and collapsed, her arm knocking a row of bottles onto the floor. Mrs. Breuer’s body fell to the side into a pile of dirty clothes.
Glass shattered and Tommy sprung to his feet. His eyes, unadjusted to the dark, only saw the shape of someone trying to stand. He instinctively grabbed her by the neck and thrashed her around the room.
“Wait, Tommy,” she gasped.
Tommy stumbled over his mother’s body and tossed Natalia to the side. Her skull slammed into the sharp corner of the dresser, a jagged piece of bone puncturing her brain. Her world went black almost instantly. Her body slithered limp onto the carpet.
Tommy blindly reached for the lamp on his dresser, knocking the remaining bottles to the floor. They bounced off Natalia’s body and rolled to the wall. Tommy flicked the switch and sat back onto the bed. It squeaked underneath him. He rolled over Natalia with his foot. Her blank eyes stared up at the ceiling, the same way she did when he was on top of her. Her body spasmed the same way it did when he shoved himself inside her. Still, it took him several minutes before he remembered her name.